How people with visual impairments can stay safe from cyberthreats

In 2023, Tim Utzig, a blind student from Baltimore, lost a thousand dollars to a laptop scam on X. Tim had been a long-time follower of a well-known sports journalist. When that journalist’s account started posting about a “charity sale” of brand-new MacBook Pros, Tim jumped at the chance to get a deal on a laptop he needed for his studies. After a few quick messages, he sent over the money.

Unfortunately, the journalist’s account had been hacked, and Tim’s cash went straight to scammers. The red flags were strictly visual: the page had been flagged as “temporarily restricted”, and both the bio and the Following list had changed. However, Tim’s screen reader — the software that converts on-screen text and graphics into speech — didn’t announce any of those warnings.

Screen readers allow blind users to navigate the digital world like everyone else. However, this community remains uniquely vulnerable. Even for sighted users, spotting a fake website is a challenge; for someone with a visual impairment, it’s an even steeper uphill battle.

Beyond screen readers, there are specialized mobile apps and services designed to assist the blind and low-vision community, with Be My Eyes being one of the most popular. The app connects users with sighted volunteers via a live video call to tackle everyday tasks — like setting an oven dial or locating an object on a desk. Be My Eyes also features integrated AI that can scan and narrate text or identify objects in the user’s environment.

But can these tools go beyond daily chores? Can they actually flag a phishing attempt or catch the hidden fine print when someone is opening a bank account?

Today we explore the specific online hurdles visually impaired users face, when it makes sense to lean on human or virtual assistants, and how to stay secure when using these types of services.

Common cyberthreats facing the blind and low-vision community

To start, let’s clarify the difference between these two groups. Low-vision users still rely on their remaining sight, even though their visual function is significantly reduced. To navigate digital interfaces, they often use screen magnifiers, extra-large fonts, and high-contrast settings. For them, phishing sites and emails are particularly dangerous. It’s easy to miss intentional typos — known as typosquatting — in a domain name or email address, such as the recent example of rnicrosoft{.}com.

Blind users navigate primarily by sound, using screen readers and specific touch gestures. Interestingly, though, unlike those with low vision, blind users are more likely to spot a phishing site using a screen reader: as the software reads the URL aloud, the user will hear that something is off. However, if a service — whether legitimate or malicious — isn’t fully compatible with screen readers, the risk of falling victim to a scam increases. This is exactly what happened to Tim Utzig.

It’s important to remember that screen magnifiers and readers are basic accessibility tools. They’re designed to enlarge or narrate an interface — not act as a security suite. They can’t warn the user of a threat on their own. That’s where more advanced software — tools that can analyze images and files, flag suspicious language, and describe the broader context of what’s happening on-screen — comes into play.

When to lean on an assistant

Be My Eyes is a major player in the accessibility space, boasting around 900 000 users and over nine million volunteers. Available on Windows, Android, and iOS, it bridges the gap by connecting blind and low-vision users with sighted volunteers via video calls for help with everyday tasks. For example, if someone wants to run a Synthetics cycle on their washing machine but can’t find the right button, they can hop into the app. It connects them with the first available volunteer speaking their language, who then uses the smartphone’s camera to guide them. The service is currently available in 32 languages.

In 2023, the app expanded its capabilities with the release of Be My AI — a virtual assistant powered by OpenAI’s GPT-4. Users take a photo, and the AI analyzes the image to provide a detailed text description, which it also reads aloud. Users can even open a chat window to ask follow-up questions. This got us thinking: could this AI actually spot a phishing site?

As an experiment, we uploaded a screenshot of a fake social media sign-in page to Be My Eyes. On a phone, you can do this by selecting a photo in your gallery or files, hitting Share, and choosing Describe with Be My Eyes. In Windows, you can upload a screenshot directly.

At first, the AI gave us a detailed description of the page. We then followed up in the chat: “Can I trust this page?” The AI flagged the domain name error immediately, advised us to close the fake login page, and suggested typing the official URL directly into the browser, or to use the official Facebook app.

We saw the same positive results when testing a phishing email. In fact, the AI flagged the scam during its initial description of the message. It wrapped up with a warning: “This looks like a suspicious email. It’s best not to open any attachments or click any links. Instead, navigate to the official website or app manually, or call the number listed on their official site”.

Beyond just spotting cyberthreats, Be My AI is a solid sidekick for navigating online stores, banking apps, and digital services. For instance, the AI can help you to:

• Read descriptions, names, and prices when a store’s website or app doesn’t support screen readers or large fonts
• Scan those tricky terms and conditions — often buried in tiny text or otherwise inaccessible to a screen reader — when you’re signing up for a subscription or opening a bank account
• Pull key info directly from product cards or instruction manuals

The risks of relying on Be My AI

The most common hiccup with AI is hallucinations, where the language model distorts text, skips crucial details, or invents words out of thin air. When it comes to cyberthreats, an AI’s misplaced confidence in a malicious site or email can be dangerous. Furthermore, AI isn’t immune to prompt injection attacks, which scammers use to trick AI agents beyond just Be My AI.

Even though the AI passed our test, you shouldn’t rely on it unquestioningly. There’s no guarantee it’ll get it right every time. This is a vital point for the blind and low-vision community, as a neural network can often feel like the only eyes available.

At the end of every response, Be My AI suggests checking in with a volunteer if you’re still unsure. However, when you’re trying to spot a fake webpage, we advise against this. You have no way of knowing how tech-savvy or trustworthy a random volunteer might be. Besides, you risk accidentally exposing sensitive data like your email address or password. Before connecting with a stranger, make sure they won’t see anything confidential on your screen. Better yet, use the app’s dedicated feature to create a private group of family, friends, or trusted contacts. This ensures your video call goes to people you actually know, rather than a random volunteer.

To stay safe, we recommend installing a trusted security tool on all your devices. These programs are designed to block phishing attempts and prevent you from landing on malicious sites. Another practical recommendation for visually impaired users is to use a password manager. These apps will only auto-fill credentials on the legitimate, saved website; they won’t be fooled by a clever domain spoof.

How Be My AI handles and stores your data

According to the Be My Eyes privacy policy, video calls with volunteers may be recorded and stored to provide the service, ensure safety, enforce the terms of service, and improve the products. When you use Be My AI, your images and text prompts are sent to OpenAI to generate a response. This data is processed on servers located in the U.S., and OpenAI uses it only to fulfill your specific request. The policy explicitly states that user images and queries aren’t used to train AI models.

Photos and videos are encrypted both in transit and at rest, and the company takes steps to strip away sensitive information. It’s worth noting that video call recordings can be retained indefinitely unless you request their deletion — in which case they’re typically wiped within 30 days. Data from Be My AI interactions is stored for up to 30 days unless you delete it manually within the app. If you decide to close your account, your personal data may be held for up to 90 days. At any time, you can opt out of data sharing, or request the deletion of your existing data by contacting the Be My Eyes support team.

How to use Be My Eyes safely

Despite Be My Eyes’ claims regarding privacy, you should still follow a few ground rules when using the service:

• Use Be My AI for a first-pass on suspicious emails or pages, but don’t treat it as the only source of truth. Specialized security software is better at identifying and neutralizing threats.
• If a site, email, or message feels off, don’t touch any links or attachments. Instead, manually type the official website address into your browser, or open the official app to verify the info.
• Remember: a volunteer sees exactly what your camera sees. Make sure it isn’t capturing things it shouldn’t, like a safe code or an open passport. Avoid sharing your name, showing your face, or revealing too much of your surroundings. Be extra careful about reflections that might show you or your personal details. Only show what is absolutely necessary for the task at hand.
• Stick to your inner circle. Create a group in the app and add your friends and family. This ensures your video calls go to people you know — not a random volunteer.
• Don’t use Be My AI to read documents that contain confidential info. Remember, your images and text prompts are sent to OpenAI for processing and generating a response.
• Remember to delete chats you no longer need. Otherwise, they’ll hang around for 30 days.
• If you need to read something personal or confidential, consider apps with real-time reading features like Envision, Seeing AI, or Lookout. These apps process data locally on your device rather than sending it to the cloud.